compatible livestock?.

In a 55 gallon marine with 40lb and 60lb of Live rock ;D
Snowflake eel
Tomato clown
Dwarf lionfish zebra
Marine beta
White spotted Toby puffer
Coral banded shrimp
Pincussion sea urchin
Dwarf zebra hermit crabs
Turban snails
Mexican turbo snail
Brittle sea star
Fighting conch
Tiger cowrie
Halloween hermit crab
Blue electric hermit crab

 

Why did you start another thread?Did you think you were going to get a different answer?: O.K. I am game. Not a chance.

http://www.3reef.com/forums/tropical-fish/these-fish-compatible-2-a-130874.html

 

No this time I added different inverts and what does I am game mean and not a chance?

 

Pufferfish, even tobies are known for killing lionfish. The tomato clown will probably kill every single fish in there. IMO a 55 is a little skinny for an eel but it should be fine.

 

Here is my reply from your other thread and just to help you a little instead of starting a new thread all the time just keep adjusting the one you already started. Helps to keep the site from becoming a cluttered mess.
I think you are going to need a larger tank.You are quickly going to discover that unless you can seperate what you "want" from what you can "have". You are setting yourself up for failure and the death of the fish you love. Predator tanks can become extremely dirty. Adding alot of them to a small tank usually ends in disaster. Make sure you research each fish/invert thoroughly before attempting to add them.
Green spotted puffers start off life living in brackish water. Only when mature do they tolerate full salinity in a SW tank. They can also be highly aggresive to other fish.
I would choose between the Lion,Betta or Eel. While one of these should be O.K. in your tank all three would not.IMO
The addition of the Tomato clown first may or may not be a problem but keep in mind these can be highly aggresive especially with new tank mates.
I would also not put a Pincushion Urchin in a tank with an Eel for fear of it becoming injured by it.
Horseshoe crabs do not do well in captivity and are one of the creatures I believe belongs in the ocean.

 

The tomato is being moved to a 30g

 

Your inverts are compatible but with such a small tank feeding all of them may be an issue.
Heres LA views on the Fighting Conch.
Praised for their hardiness, the Fighting Conch requires open, deep sand beds in which it can forage for food. Though multiple Fighting Conches should be housed in larger systems, single specimens are suited for any size reef aquarium. Keep in mind that the Fighting Conch has a voracious appetite; as such, supplemental feeding is required in smaller systems and recommended in even the largest aquarium setups. Also you will not be able to add shrimp with the fish on your list.

 

If you look I have new invert choices and new fish choices

 

He looked....AGAIN.....and had the same reply. As did you. He's only trying to save you $$$$$ and trouble.

 

+1

Looks to me like the same basic lineup of fish in all four threads-

http://www.3reef.com/forums/tropical-fish/these-fish-compatible-130202.html

http://www.3reef.com/forums/tropical-fish/these-fish-compatible-2-a-130874.html

http://www.3reef.com/forums/tropical-fish/these-fish-compatible-3-a-130887.html

http://www.3reef.com/forums/inverts/compatible-livestock-131120.html#post1306561

You were told in your first thread that a 55g is not a suitable tank for multiple predators. If you're really that determined, you don't need our approval.