Coral polyp like thing

These red huge polyp like corals are popping up all over this the biggest. They aren't bad I don't think but have no clue what they are

Don't mind my Xenia weed

 

Are they an anemone? No skeletal structure?

If so probably a variation on Majano. If they are reproducing fast you may want to take action if you do not like the look of them. Sometimes cutting down on feedings helps if they are pest anemones. Nice color brown though.

Or do you think this is some kind of Palys?

 

Looks like a wild paly from the south florida area...i have some in my tank...they reproduce like crazy..

 

I had a few majanos in another tank, those spread like a super weed... There are about in the last 3-6 months but they are huge! Here are a few more

Florida is where they originated from, it started on a coral I got from the frag farmer...


pics

 

All I can say is I have seen very pretty Majanos, some looking like small versions of BTA's. The one has what looks like bubble tips.

 

Yeh I was gonna say that one on the right doesnt look right to me..lol

 

So Is it best to just kill them off ? The one on the right is the only one that seems to have bubbles.

That one is also squished up against another rock. (had a small rock avalanche... Damn urchin)

Will joes juice work?

 

Probably if you repeat the process. Me I would do away with them asap if they are a pest anemone, I would wait and get other opinions as well.

 

if you like them leave them....even if they are majanos they wont spread over night....ive had a little patch of 10 green ones that "i think" look cool for 2 years....they havnt spread at all,and there not hard to kill

 

boiling water kills them fast and they wont grow back,aptasia is a different story