Would the following fish make my tank overstocked

My issue is not with saint, but with this trend of seeking advice and then disregarding advice given until desired answer it obtained.
Basically if you are unsure of something with regard to this hobby, you ask for input and then disregard that input routinely. If something sounds or feels off or wrong it usually is and common sense should prevail.
Everyone should provide their own experience, but the weight of one post should not invalidate the others.
Yes I made my share of mistakes in this hobby when I started out, but we did not have the resources that hobbyist have available today, nor the knowledge base.
Enthusiasm is one of the things that makes this a wonderful hobby but it needs to tempered with common sense and a deep respect for the animals we keep.

 

Yea... I understand........ I might just end up putting in the 2 firefish OR 1 royal gramma